The Complete Guide to Tax Implications of Paying Off Your Rental Property



The Insider @ Houst
Last updated on
September 6, 2023
February 6, 2024

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Suspendisse varius enim in eros elementum tristique. Duis cursus, mi quis viverra ornare, eros dolor interdum nulla, ut commodo diam libero vitae erat. Aenean faucibus nibh et justo cursus id rutrum lorem imperdiet. Nunc ut sem vitae risus tristique posuere.

The Complete Guide to Tax Implications of Paying Off Your Rental Property

Airbnb Management Services by Houst | Short-Term Rental Experts

About Houst

Houst is a leading property management company specialising in short-term and medium-term bookings in eight countries. With over 7 years of experience and managing over 300,000 bookings, we help homeowners make the most of their properties.

Learn More

Investing in rental properties offers a smart avenue for generating a steady income. This approach covers the property's costs and brings in a monthly surplus for personal savings and desires. Over time, with consistent renting, you might accumulate adequate funds to settle the mortgage on either your rental property or your primary residence.

On the surface, eliminating your rental property's mortgage seems promising. Your monthly cash influx substantially boosts by diverting your rental earnings away from the mortgage. However, if your investment property and your primary abode carry mortgages, the ultimate choice revolves around deciding whether to prioritise the rental property or your main dwelling for repayment.

Selecting between paying off your primary home or rental property hinges on your priorities. Clearing the mortgage on your rental place amplifies your cash flow and ownership stake, whereas settling your primary residence's mortgage ensures a secure shelter. Another critical aspect to factor in is the respective interest rates. This decision involves a mix of intricate considerations that demand careful evaluation. Well, let’s discuss what are the tax implications of paying off a rental property in detail.

Table of Contents

What are the Tax Implications of Paying Off a Rental Property?

The income stemming from renting out a property holds tax obligations per the Australia Taxation Office guidelines. This mandates the declaration of the income derived from your investment property's rentals. Nonetheless, the silver lining exists in the ability to offset expenses, like utilities and maintenance costs, resulting in the taxable income encompassing solely the net earnings post-deductibles.

Now, let's examine the tax implications of paying off your rental property's mortgage. Without mortgage payments, your income will naturally increase, leading to higher taxes on your rental revenue. Typically, this remains more favourable than the continuous monthly mortgage outlay. However, it's essential to factor in your tax bracket and unique circumstances to gauge the tax outcomes linked to mortgage settlement precisely.

In scenarios where negative gearing forms a pivotal aspect of your ongoing investment strategy, clearing the mortgage will promptly reshape the scenario. We’ve compiled a list of potential tax deductions for those who own an investment property, which could potentially help save you money.

  • Landlord insurance
  • Property management fees
  • Cleaning fees and council rates
  • Legal expenses and land tax
  • Land tax
  • Travel expenses for collection and inspections
  • Advertising fees for finding new tenants
  • Costs of inspection
  • Repairs and maintenance
  • Home contents

Remember to keep track of all these expenses associated with your investment property, even after paying off the mortgage. 

Calculator, tax forms, and a small model of a house on a desk, representing the tax implications of owning and paying off a rental property

Should You Pay Off a Rental Property: Factors to Consider

Deciding whether to pay off your rental property or continue holding a mortgage on it is a complex decision with potential ramifications for your overall financial health. The answer may not be the same for everyone and will depend on a variety of individual factors, from current debt levels to long-term investment goals. Here's a more detailed look at the aspects you should consider:

Equity and Debt

When you pay off a property, you're essentially converting a liquid asset (cash) into an illiquid asset (real estate). While this can be beneficial for building equity and reducing your debt load, it can also tie up funds that might be better used for other investment opportunities. On the other hand, paying off debt can offer a guaranteed "return" in the form of interest you're no longer required to pay, which may or may not be more advantageous than potential returns from other investments.

Investment Potential

Your long-term financial goals should be a significant factor in your decision-making process. If your primary aim is long-term wealth accumulation, then you might find it more beneficial to hold onto the mortgage and use your available funds to invest in another property or different kind of asset. The additional rental income or investment returns could potentially outpace the interest you're paying on the existing mortgage, resulting in a net positive impact on your wealth.

Timing and Retirement

If retirement is on the horizon, you may find it beneficial to pay off your rental property to reduce your overall financial liabilities and secure a steady income stream. However, if retirement is several decades away, the compounding growth of alternative investments might be more lucrative in the long run. Additionally, in an environment where interest rates are high, it might make more sense to prioritise paying off debt, especially for properties that are financed through a buy-to-let mortgage with higher-than-average interest rates.

Interest Rates

Generally speaking, if you have multiple debts, it makes sense to pay off the one with the highest interest rate first, whether that's the mortgage on your primary residence or your rental property. This approach minimises the total amount of interest you'll pay over the long term, which is a crucial factor for anyone focused on maximising their net worth.

Deliberation is Key

Making a decision about whether to pay off your rental property is not something to take lightly. Consider factors like your age, the state of your emergency fund, your overall debt-to-income ratio, and the potential tax implications of your decision. Assess the potential gains from mortgage settlement against the long-term benefits of holding onto your mortgage and investing elsewhere. Speak with financial and tax advisors to fully understand the implications of your decision.

Financial advisor sitting with a couple, reviewing paperwork, highlighting the importance of consulting professionals for tax and financial planning related to rental properties.

Is Refinancing Your Rental Property to Pay Off Your Primary Residence a Good Idea?

The decision to refinance your rental property to pay off the mortgage on your primary residence is complex and can depend on a variety of factors, including your financial goals, current market conditions, and the performance of your rental property. Below, we delve into some critical aspects that can help determine if this move is a strategic one for you.

Advantages of Refinancing

Refinancing your rental property can offer you financial flexibility and unlock different opportunities for wealth generation. If you have significant equity in your rental property and mortgage rates are favourably low, you can refinance the property and use the cash-out to pay off or reduce the mortgage on your primary residence. This can be an excellent strategy for those looking to reduce their debt burden while potentially maintaining or even increasing their overall net worth.

Interest Rate Advantage

Lower interest rates are one of the most enticing aspects of refinancing. If the rate is significantly lower than what you're paying on your primary residence's mortgage, you may save a considerable amount of money over the life of the loan. Also, rental property loans are sometimes offered at more competitive rates, especially if the property has a solid rental history and the investor has a good credit score. The savings garnered from a lower interest rate could effectively make the financial puzzle of maintaining multiple properties much more manageable.

Choosing the Right Moment

Timing is everything when it comes to refinancing. Often, the best time to refinance is when the value of your rental property has appreciated substantially since your initial investment. Not only will this likely give you a better interest rate, but it can also increase the amount of equity you can tap into. Combine this with a period of historically low-interest rates, and you have an opportune window to make your move.

It's also crucial to consider the state of your primary residence's mortgage. If you're nearing the end of the mortgage term, the interest savings from refinancing may not be as impactful. However, if you still have many years left, refinancing can make a significant difference.

Market Dynamics and Property Value Trends

Keep an eye on both the broader economic landscape and local real estate market trends. Factors such as job growth in the area where your rental property is located can positively impact your property's value, making refinancing more beneficial. Similarly, if there's a forecast of rising interest rates, it might be advantageous to refinance sooner rather than later.

Being attuned to market dynamics also means considering the state of the rental market. If rental demand is high and you've been able to increase your rates, the additional income can serve as a cushion for the refinancing process, making it a less risky move.

Graph comparing the financial trade-offs between paying off a rental property mortgage and keeping it, emphasizing the importance of individual financial circumstances.

Benefits of Refinancing Your Rental Property

Refinancing your rental property comes with several strategic advantages that can significantly influence your overall financial landscape. Here's an expanded look at some of the compelling reasons to consider this financial move.

Reduced Monthly Payments

One of the most immediate benefits of refinancing is the reduction in your monthly mortgage payments. Lower interest rates or a longer loan term can lead to significant monthly savings. This freed-up cash flow can be instrumental for your other investments or personal expenditures. If you've been feeling the pinch from various financial commitments, refinancing can be a breath of fresh air, providing immediate financial relief.

Property Expansion 

Refinancing can unlock the equity built up in your current investment property, providing you with the means to acquire additional properties. This expansion not only diversifies your investment portfolio but also amplifies your avenues for income. Essentially, you can leverage one successful investment to make another, taking a step further in your wealth-building journey.

Enhanced Investment Quality

If your rental property is showing signs of age or is no longer attracting the rental income it once did, you can use the funds from refinancing to renovate and upgrade it. Enhancements could range from minor cosmetic changes like a new paint job to significant improvements like installing energy-efficient appliances or a new HVAC system. These upgrades make your property more appealing to potential tenants and may justify higher rental rates, thereby boosting your return on investment (ROI).

Consolidating Debt

Debt can be a significant burden, especially when you have multiple loans with varying interest rates and terms. Refinancing your rental property can give you a way to consolidate these debts into a single, more manageable payment plan. This streamlining can not only make managing your finances easier but can also offer a lower interest rate, saving you money in the long run.

Accelerated Loan Repayment

Sometimes the focus isn't necessarily on reducing monthly payments, but on getting rid of debt as quickly as possible. Refinancing can facilitate this by restructuring your loan terms. You could opt for a loan with a shorter term, which may come with higher monthly payments but will allow you to pay off the loan much faster. While this may strain your monthly budget, the long-term benefit is the saving on interest payments over the life of the loan.

Refinancing is a tool that, when used wisely, can be incredibly advantageous. However, it's essential to consider the costs involved, including closing costs and any potential penalties for paying off your existing mortgage early. A thorough evaluation of these factors against the potential benefits will help you make a well-informed decision.

Person writing a list of potential tax deductions for rental property owners on a whiteboard, underscoring the importance of tracking expenses.

Selling Your Rental Property to Settle Your Primary Residence Mortgage

Deciding whether to sell your rental property to clear your primary residence mortgage is a nuanced choice influenced by various factors. Let's delve into key considerations:

The significance of your current life stage cannot be understated. Choices made before retirement may diverge significantly from those made early in your investment journey. During the initial phases, a steady stream of rental income holds more sway, offering potential benefits over the long haul.

While selling your investment property to settle your primary residence mortgage may seem logical, the timing within the property market's dynamics matters considerably. Viability depends on the market state.

A critical factor to contemplate is the projection of your property's future valuation. Should the outlook hint at a decline in value, the decision to sell might be prudent, offering a chance to reclaim your investment before it potentially diminishes further. Conversely, retaining the investment could prove strategically advantageous in the long run if future appreciation is anticipated.

Shifting your investments is another facet to ponder. Evaluating whether transitioning to another investment aligns better with your financial goals than direct mortgage clearance is essential. It requires a thorough assessment of potential gains and trade-offs.

The implications of capital gains tax should be considered. Selling your rental property means encountering this tax, directly impacting your fiscal year's overall tax payment and potentially your tax bracket.

Moreover, timing the payment of capital gains tax is crucial. If selling one property to finance another, the timing of capital gains tax payment holds significance. Even a few months could translate into a substantial difference in the amount of tax payable, potentially extending the time needed to clear your primary residence mortgage fully.

Split image of a young family outside their new home and a property labeled 'For Rent,' showcasing the decision-making involved in managing financial commitments for different properties.

Houst Simplifies Rental Property Management

Managing short term rentals can be a headache, but Houst offers a solution. With a team of experts in holiday rental management, Houst takes care of everything for you. They handle everything from and Airbnb listings to optimising your rental yields.

Houst's focus on helping hosts earn more aligns with your goal of financial freedom. Like Houst's testimonials, your decision should lead to peace of mind. As you navigate real estate complexities, know that Houst has answers to your queries.

The Insider @ Houst

The Insider @ Houst

The Insider team at Houst is dedicated to providing up-to-date and relevant information on short-term rentals. If you have hosting inquiries, please write to us at For guest inquiries, reach out at We are here to help you navigate the world of short lets and look forward to assisting you with your needs.

The Insider @ Houst

The Insider @ Houst

The Insider team at Houst is dedicated to providing up-to-date and relevant information on short-term rentals. If you have hosting inquiries, please write to us at For guest inquiries, reach out at We are here to help you navigate the world of short lets and look forward to assisting you with your needs.

Pricing From

of your
rental revenue
The commission depends on
the property profile and location

Complete property management services

We streamline the process of short-term lets and assist in maximising your rental revenue in London.

Listing Management

  • Multi-platform listings
  • Professional photography
  • Listing creation
  • Price optimisation

Guest Management

  • Guest vetting
  • Guest check-ins
  • Linen and toiletries
  • Guest communications

Property Management

  • Cleaning and housekeeping
  • Property maintenance
  • Property insurance
  • Property management software
I hope you enjoy reading this blog post!
If you want my team to just manage your Airbnb for you, just book a call.
Click here to Get More Bookings!
See How Houst Can Elevate Your Airbnb’s Visibility
  • Listing Optimisation – Maximise your listing’s potential. Experience tangible growth.
  • Professional Photography – Captivating visuals that instantly attract guests.
  • Guest Screening – Ensuring only the best and safest guests for your property.

We hope you enjoy our blog!

If you would like to find out more about how our team can help you get the most of your Airbnb, just book a call with us.

Thank you for providing your contact information!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
J’espère que vous apprécierez la lecture de cet article de blog !
Si vous souhaitez que mon équipe gère simplement votre Airbnb pour vous, réservez simplement un appel.
Cliquez ici pour obtenir plus de réservations !
Découvrez comment Houst peut améliorer la visibilité de votre Airbnb
  • Optimisation des annonces – Maximisez le potentiel de votre annonce. Faites l’expérience d’une croissance tangible.
  • Photographie professionnelle – Des visuels captivants qui attirent instantanément les invités.
  • Filtrage des invités – Garantir uniquement les invités les meilleurs et les plus sûrs pour votre propriété.
Looking to scale your serviced accommodation?
Join Houst’s partnership program — book a call for details.
Starting your Airbnb business?
Houst can help you get started in the serviced accommodation sector:
  • Fastracked growth: Quick portfolio expansion and up to 20% booking commission for property managers.
  • Guest Support and Tech: 24/7 support and tech streamlined operations, enhancing occupancy and guest service delivery.
  • Pricing Optimisation: Increased earnings with algorithm-based pricing strategies.